Donald Trump Is an Illegitimate President.
Congress Can and Must Remove Him.

“No person shall hold any office under the United States who, having previously taken an oath, as an officer of the United States, to support the Constitution, shall have engaged in insurrection against the same, or given aid or comfort to the enemies thereof.” —14th Amendment, Section 3

To be a legitimate president under our Constitution, a person must win a free and fair election, and also must meet all constitutional eligibility requirements, such as being a natural-born citizen and at least 35 years old. When the 14th Amendment was adopted after the Civil War, the 44 words in Section 3 shown above added another eligibility requirement for holding any office, including president. It is stated in the negative as automatically disqualifying conduct, so the absence of such conduct in a person’s past is a requirement of eligibility to hold any office under the United States.

On January 6, 2021 (“Jan 6”), Trump as the sitting president incited a mob to violently attack the sitting Congress in order to prevent the certification of Trump’s electoral defeat by Joe Biden, so that Trump could then remain in power unconstitutionally. That attack satisfies every dictionary definition of “insurrection” and the legal definition as well, and so Trump’s conduct on that day met the requirement for disqualification under Section 3, and Trump therefore became ineligible to hold office again on that date. If that is true, his entire administration has had no constitutional legitimacy.

And yet, it is as if those words just don’t exist. Trump was able to run for president as the Republican Party candidate in the 2024 election, which he won (barely). He was then able to assume the power of office in January 2025, and he is accepted as president by everyone. Not surprisingly, his entire administration has been an unrelenting attack on the Constitution and the rule of law, which we feel is best understood as a second insurrection.

How Could This Possibly Be True And No One Knows It?

We believe the answer to that question includes three primary factors, each of which we discuss in detail within these pages.

1. A fog of misunderstanding. Section 3 had faded into obscurity in the 150 years since Reconstruction, so only a few constitutional scholars were even aware of its existence prior to Jan 6. Far more problematically, its sentence structure is so complex that understanding its meaning requires careful analysis, which few people take the time to do. As a result, almost everyone’s knowledge of Section 3 does not come from having read the actual text, but from what they hear or read from others, most of which is simply wrong. Please view our 3-minute Section 3 Revealed “explainer” tool to read the actual words of Section 3 and understand its meaning, and also the page History and Mystery of Section 3.

2. Supreme Court Betrayal. Because so few people understand Section 3, most people assumed that the reversal of the Colorado supreme court’s ruling by the Roberts Court in Trump v. Anderson in March 2024 meant that Trump is eligible, even though the decision was totally silent on that fundamental question. The decision left undisturbed (but also unaffirmed) the state court’s ruling that Trump is ineligible to be president, and their silence on the substance was a profound abdication of the Court’s responsibility under the Constitution to decide such matters. Critical to understand is that this decision definitely did not make Trump eligible again (only Congress can do that). However, it effectively locked a majority of the public into a false perception that Donald Trump is eligible because the Supreme Court ruled in his favor.

Largely underappreciated by all, in our opinion, is the sheer unconstitutionality of how the Court disposed of the case. They created an entirely novel “interpretation” of election law that holds that states do not have constitutional authority to disqualify candidates for federal office under Section 3, and only Congress can enforce such disqualification of Presidential candidates, through additional “legislation” that is needed. The refusal by the Court to frame Section 3 as a loss of a person’s eligibility for office that occurs automatically as a consequence of the disqualifying conduct, and instead framing the disqualification as being imposed on candidates by a governmental authority is an outright nullification of the intent of the Framers of the 14th Amendment. The Supreme Court does not have the power to rewrite the Constitution. In short, the Supreme Court itself violated the Constitution by allowing an ineligible candidate to be nominated by the Republican Party, and it was a violation of the Constitution that his name was on the ballot for election by the voters. Trump’s victory in the election did not give him the right to hold the office to which he was elected and does not give him constitutional legitimacy in office, because of his ineligibility. Congress therefore violated the Constitution when it certified Trump as President-elect on January 6, 2025; his oath of office and inauguration to power violated Section 3 directly, and every moment of this administration has lacked constitutional legitimacy. Because of this betrayal of trust and duty by the Roberts Court, America has not had a legitimate president since the end of Joe Biden’s term of office.

Moreover, even though the decision specifically refers to disqualification under Section 3, we can imagine that the argument of constitutional jurisdiction on which the decision is based could also be applied to disqualification for not meeting any eligibility requirement, including not being old enough or not being a natural-born citizen as required under Article II, or even for having already been elected to two terms as POTUS under the 22nd Amendment. Also, remember that there is no law that requires political parties to nominate eligible candidates. So, under the theory of the Constitution that is now the law after Trump v. Anderson, the political party that controls Congress at the time of a presidential election could theoretically nominate and get elected any candidate they wish regardless of constitutional eligibility. Given the willingness of this Court to allow this man to be elected in 2024, it’s hard not to see in this decision the creation of a legal precedent that would allow Trump to run again in 2028 were he to win in 2024 and retain control of Congress until 2028. That should make everyone’s blood run cold. The stunning midterm repudiation of November 2026, however, will fortunately give Democrats control of Congress through the 2028 election, removing the opportunity this decision would otherwise have given Trump. Nevertheless, this decision remains the law of the land.

How can it be argued that this decision by the Roberts Court did not give “aid and comfort” to a known insurrectionist, who is therefore by definition a domestic enemy of the Constitution, made by justices who had previously sworn an oath to support the Constitution against such enemies? We believe this decision thus at least meets the definition of having “given aid and comfort to enemies [of the Constitution]” in Section 3.

In our opinion, though, the magnitude of the abuse of judicial power and constitutional infidelity manifested in this decision can more properly be characterized as a “judicial insurrection”—especially when one also considers the many assists the Roberts Court has provided to Trump throughout this second insurrection. So, whether one trigger or both, we believe that these justices have disqualified themselves under Section 3, and that Congress must remove them from the bench in order to restore constitutional integrity to the Supreme Court. Please read more about this case, this decision, and our views in the page Supreme Betrayal.

3. Dereliction by Democrats. Finally, a hidden but crucial reason for the widespread misperception of Trump’s legitimacy is the decision made by Democratic officeholders NOT to use the power of Congress to declare Trump to have self-disqualified under Section 3 during the nearly two years they held the majorities in both Houses necessary to do so, i.e., from January 2021 through the end of 2022. Two points in time were especially consequential: first in the immediate aftermath of the failed coup, when Democrats chose instead to impeach the already self-disqualified ex-president purely to disqualify him for future office. They fell far short of conviction in the Senate, as everyone knew they would, whereas they almost certainly could have sustained a disqualification resolution under Section 3 in the days immediately after Jan 6. Then, even more consequentially, in December of 2022, Congress under Democratic leadership chose to do essentially nothing in response to the devastating evidence produced by the House Select Committee’s investigation of the Jan 6 insurrection, which revealed Trump’s role as the organizer of the coup attempt. In both instances, calls from within the caucus to invoke Section 3 in a disqualification resolution were rejected.

From what we can find in the public record, it would appear that both decisions were made based primarily on partisan political factors. In particular, there is strong evidence to support an inference that the decision in late 2022 not to invoke Section 3 disqualification was made by President Joe Biden for the purely self-interested reason that he wanted Trump to be his Republican opponent in his planned run for reelection. If true, such a decision would represent a profound moral failure by Biden and a clear violation of his oath to “preserve, protect, and defend the Constitution” to the best of his ability. We believe that President Biden, Speaker Pelosi, and Majority Leader Schumer owe the American people a full explanation of why Section 3 was not invoked in a Congressional declaration of self-disqualification in December 2022. Please refer to the page Democrat Dereliction for more details.

Whatever the reasons were, once that decision was made, Democrats simply turned their backs on Section 3. They essentially said nothing on the subject during the course of the Trump v. Anderson litigation and provided no help or support to the Anderson side. Neither the Democrats nor the DOJ filed an amicus brief in Trump v. Anderson advocating for upholding the lower court’s ruling of ineligibility. In short, Section 3 simply became an inconvenient and uncomfortable truth for Democrats, and it remains so today, with catastrophic results.

The unqualified acceptance by Democrats of Donald Trump as the Republican opponent unquestionably contributed to the general fog of misunderstanding about Section 3. After all, how could Trump not be eligible under Section 3 if the Democrats aren’t making that case?

More importantly, however, the failure of the Democrats to exercise the power of Congress to enforce Trump’s disqualification under Section 3 made possible everything that has happened since then, namely the politically corrupted Trump v. Anderson decision by SCOTUS and the second insurrection that we are experiencing now. Had Democratic elected leaders made the right decision when they held power, none of it could have happened.

When viewed through the lens of Section 3, we see a scope of betrayal of the Constitution and the American people by key people in high office that is simply staggering. The oath of office seems to have become just a bunch of words you say in a ceremony when you take power, like a ritual chant that doesn’t really mean anything. The Oath of Office page discusses how crucial swearing loyalty to the Constitution is to the preservation of the democracy, and we believe the failure by elected leaders to honor their oaths of office on a massive scale is a major cause of this collapse of the rule of law under the Constitution.

What Can Be Done?

First, we believe that there needs to be a Great Awakening in which the American people come to understand the truth of Trump’s illegitimacy, because legitimacy is at the heart of the “consent of the governed” and the moral authority of a leader to lead. It is worth remembering that it was Trump himself who attacked Obama’s legitimacy on the basis of the natural-born citizen requirement and Biden’s legitimacy on an equally fictitious allegation of election rigging. That Trump is actually an illegitimate POTUS is a great irony of history. We ask you to help in this process by spreading the word to those you know.

Also, everyone must understand the magnitude of this dire constitutional emergency that has existed since January 2025. Not only have we not had a legitimate POTUS, but the person that has been wielding the power of that office is doing so in a second attempt to subvert the Constitution and rule of law—to establish himself as a dictator starting on “Day 1,” as he promised during the campaign. Note also that this is the very threat to the democracy that Section 3 was intended to prevent at any level of government, most importantly the presidency. Amplifying the threat exponentially, a captive Supreme Court is an active partner in this insurrection. There is simply no precedent in our history for this crisis, and no roadmap exists for recovering constitutional order.

We would start with first principles:

(a) Congress as the Article I branch has the most power of all the branches granted under the Constitution, including the right to remove for cause officers of the other branches. So, the only path to resolving this crisis is for Congress to remove Trump from an office he has no legal right to hold.

(b) Impeachment is the mechanism for removing legitimate officeholders but is not required for Congress to declare an officeholder to be illegitimate and the office therefore to be vacant. A majority vote in both Houses is sufficient for such removal. Congress has done this previously, including for cause based on Section 3 disqualification, but never of course for POTUS or Supreme Court justices.

(c) Conduct which self-disqualifies a person under Section 3 is the only “high crime” that does not require impeachment for removal from office, because the office immediately becomes vacant when its occupant loses eligibility to hold office. For this reason, Congress can replace all nine justices. Impeachment is therefore not required for Congress to remove these faithless justices from the bench, nor does the Supreme Court have the power to overrule Congress on that matter.

Removing Trump from an office he has no right to hold raises an immediate further question: what happens to the Vice Presidency? Under the Twentieth Amendment, if a President-elect fails to qualify, the Vice President-elect acts as President until a qualified President takes office — a provision written for exactly this kind of situation. Whether that default should govern here, though, turns on a separate question: whether Vance’s own conduct since taking office, as a central figure in an administration we believe has carried out a second insurrection against the Constitution, independently disqualifies him under Section 3 in his own right. We aren’t resolving that question on this page. It is a decision only Congress can make, with the same authority it has long exercised in judging the qualifications of its own members and other officers of government, and it will be one of the central choices facing Congress as it charts the path back to constitutional government.

Restoring constitutional order will be very complicated legally because everything done by this administration lacks constitutional legitimacy. Two consequences of Trump’s illegitimacy, however, are especially significant once the rule of law is restored. One is that none of Trump’s pardons can be relied upon to protect against prosecution (and reincarceration) by law enforcement. The fact that they were all corruptly granted is secondary to the fact that Trump lacked the constitutional authority to pardon anyone for anything. The second consequence is that Trump does not enjoy the blanket criminal immunity for “official acts” granted to presidents by the Roberts Court, since he was not legitimately the president and none of his acts were official. We believe that it is absolutely essential to the restoration of the rule of law that Trump and all of his accomplices in this second insurrection be held fully accountable under the law for all crimes committed while they held power. This will put a huge burden on the court system but is absolutely necessary. All of these people simply must be held accountable for their actions if there is to be rule of law again under the Constitution.

Assuming again that Democrats actually take control of both Houses of Congress in January 2027, they will have the power constitutionally to pass such a resolution to remove Trump from office under Section 3. But will they do it?

We believe that the answer to that question will be “YES” if the people of this country join together and demand that they act—not as a partisan act of retribution but in response to a mandate from the people of this nation to restore the Constitution. So, we ask everyone to make their voice heard and demand of their Representatives and Senators that they invoke Section 3 to stop this second insurrection being conducted from inside our government. Visit the page Join Our Cause if you would like to help make this happen.